The Injury Dilemma: Eddie Howe's Defensive Conundrum
Newcastle United boss Eddie Howe faces a major defensive crisis as full-back Tino Livramento's injury threatens to derail plans for the upcoming clash against Chelsea.

Newcastle United boss Eddie Howe has admitted there are “worrying signs” over Tino Livramento’s fitness after the full-back was forced off with a knee problem in midweek. With the Magpies' defensive options already stretched, the 23-year-old is now a major doubt to face Chelsea, casting uncertainty over Howe’s plans for the crucial Premier League clash.Newcastle United booked their place in the Carabao Cup semi-finals with a dramatic 2-1 victory over Fulham at St James’ Park, but the win came at a potential cost. Livramento was forced off late in the contest after appearing to injure his knee, receiving treatment on the pitch before being withdrawn in the 76th minute. The defender was later seen walking around with an ice pack strapped to his left knee, raising immediate concerns.Livramento had been asked to fill in at left-back due to Newcastle’s growing injury list in defence, with Lewis Hall unavailable and several senior options already sidelined. His withdrawal further underlined how thin Eddie Howe’s resources are at the back, especially given the physical demands of a packed December schedule. The timing of the injury could hardly be worse for the Magpies, who found out earlier this week that Dan Burn had suffered a rib fracture and will be out for a few weeks.Attention quickly turns to Saturday’s Premier League meeting with Chelsea, where Newcastle are set to face another tough test. With Livramento now a doubt and uncertainty surrounding the severity of the issue, Howe is once again faced with difficult decisions as he attempts to patch together a defensive unit amid an ongoing injury crisis.Speaking after the Fulham win, Eddie Howe did little to downplay his concern over Livramento’s condition. “It looks like a knee problem and Tino’s had issues with knee injuries before,” the Newcastle head coach explained. “So the fact he had to come off and he’s such an honest, dependable lad – that sends worrying signs, really, for his participation maybe in the Chelsea game. Let’s wait and see.”Howe’s comments reflected both the immediate concern and the longer-term context surrounding Livramento’s fitness history. The defender spent more than a month sidelined earlier this season with ligament damage to the same knee, and previously endured a lengthy absence following an anterior cruciate ligament injury sustained in April 2022 while at Southampton.Looking for smarter football bets? Get expert previews, data-driven predictions & winning insights with GOAL Tips on Telegram. Join our growing community now!Livramento’s importance to Newcastle has grown steadily since his arrival, with the 23-year-old becoming one of Howe’s most trusted and versatile players. Naturally a right-back, he has frequently been deployed on the left or asked to adapt to different roles when injuries strike elsewhere in the squad. That flexibility has been invaluable during a season repeatedly disrupted by fitness setbacks.The current campaign has already tested Livramento physically, with his earlier knee problem ruling him out for several weeks between October and November. His return was seen as a significant boost, helping to restore balance and energy to a defence that has struggled for continuity. Any repeat absence would therefore be a major blow, both tactically and psychologically.Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reportingBeyond the immediate concern, the injury highlights a broader issue facing Newcastle as they juggle domestic and cup commitments. With Burn, Sven Botman, Kieran Trippier and Emil Krafth all unavailable, Howe has been forced into creative solutions, including deploying midfielders in defensive roles. The strain on a small core of fit defenders has become increasingly apparent.The Newcastle boss also addressed the wider injury picture, offering a more optimistic update on another defensive option. “Lewis (Hall), we’re more positive on. He couldn’t play today. He felt some tightness in his hamstring, but he has a chance for Chelsea,” Howe said. “We’ve got a number of injuries to the same position, which is never good.”All eyes will now be on Livramento’s recovery over the coming days as Newcastle assess whether he can be risked against Chelsea. The short turnaround between matches leaves limited time for rehabilitation, and Howe may be reluctant to gamble given the player’s history with knee injuries. A late decision appears inevitable.Should Livramento be ruled out, Howe will again have to reshuffle his back line, potentially leaning on players out of position or those returning from minor issues. The Newcastle manager has already acknowledged the precarious nature of the situation, admitting he is running out of solutions as injuries continue to mount in the same areas.
Worrying Signs for Newcastle's Defensive Line
Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe has expressed serious concerns over Tino Livramento's fitness following a knee injury sustained during the midweek Carabao Cup clash against Fulham. With the Magpies already facing defensive frailties, Livramento's potential absence against Chelsea has left Howe with a major selection headache.
Impact of Livramento's Potential Absence
Livramento's versatility and reliability have made him a crucial asset for Newcastle this season. The 23-year-old's adaptability in various defensive roles has been instrumental in coping with the team's injury woes. His absence would not only disrupt Howe's tactical plans but also add to the mounting defensive challenges the team is facing.
Eddie Howe's Injury Concerns
The injury to Livramento compounds Newcastle's existing defensive problems, with key players like Dan Burn sidelined with injuries. Howe's makeshift defensive solutions, including deploying midfielders in defensive roles, underscore the team's vulnerability at the back. The manager's options are limited as the injury list continues to grow in crucial defensive positions.
The Race Against Time for Livramento's Recovery
As Newcastle prepare to face Chelsea, all eyes are on Livramento's recovery timeline. With a hectic schedule ahead, Howe faces a race against time to determine the full-back's availability for the important fixture. The manager must weigh the risks of rushing Livramento back into action against the potential long-term implications of exacerbating his knee injury.
Remaining Optimistic Amidst Adversity
Despite the challenges, Howe remains cautiously optimistic about other defensive options like Lewis Hall potentially returning for the Chelsea game. However, the ongoing injury crisis in key defensive positions presents a significant challenge for Newcastle's backline stability. Howe's ability to navigate through these testing times will be crucial for the team's performance in the upcoming matches.

